Netflix's 'Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story' Faces Criticism and Defends Its Portrayal
Netflix's latest series, 'Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story,' created by Ryan Murphy, has ignited a fierce debate and criticism from the Menendez family and other stakeholders. The show, which premiered on September 19, dramatizes the true story of Lyle and Erik Menendez, who were convicted of murdering their parents in 1989.
The series has been labeled as a 'grotesque shock drama' by the Menendez family, who claim that the show is filled with inaccuracies and blatant falsehoods. Erik Menendez, through his wife, issued a statement criticizing the portrayal as 'disheartening slander' and accused the series of fabricating a distorted image of his brother, Lyle. He also expressed disappointment that the show has regressed the understanding of the abuses they faced, particularly male victims of sexual abuse.
Ryan Murphy's Defense
Ryan Murphy has defended the series, noting that Erik Menendez made his statement without having seen the show. Murphy emphasized that the series dedicates a significant portion to exploring the abuse the brothers claim to have endured. He stated that the show presents their narrative carefully and allows them the opportunity to discuss their experiences openly. Murphy also highlighted the importance of including the parents' perspectives, acknowledging that addressing all viewpoints can be contentious.
The show's portrayal of an incestuous relationship between the brothers, a claim dismissed by journalist Robert Rand as 'a fantasy,' has been a major point of contention. The Menendez family and some critics have criticized this aspect as a fabrication and an unnecessary addition to the narrative.
Family and Public Reaction
Members of the extended Menendez family have also spoken out against the series, stating that Ryan Murphy never contacted them and expressing their support for Erik and Lyle. The family's statement condemned the show as 'a phobic, repulsive, anachronistic nightmare of a serial episode' filled with inaccuracies and blatant falsehoods.
Despite the controversy, the series has garnered significant viewership, with over 12 million views during its opening weekend. However, critics have largely responded negatively, describing the show as 'exhausting' and 'repetitive.'
Upcoming Documentary
In response to the criticism, Netflix has announced an upcoming documentary titled 'The Menendez Brothers,' set to be released on October 7. The documentary will feature extensive audio interviews with Lyle and Erik Menendez, among others connected to the trial, providing an alternative perspective on the events.
The controversy surrounding 'Monsters' is not new for Ryan Murphy, who faced similar criticism for his previous series on Jeffrey Dahmer. The next season of 'Monsters' has been confirmed to focus on the infamous killer Ed Gein, portrayed by Charlie Hunnam.
